Supermarket clean sweep threatens small shops
Well, what a disappointment. The Competition Commission appears to be living in a blissful parallel universe where Mr Cleaver the butcher and Mrs Large-Whyte, the baker, thrive on the same High Street as Sir Terry, the supermarket boss. Well it ain't so. Not in London anyway. This paper has been overwhelmed with responses from ordinary Londoners who have lost much loved local traders since we launched our Save Our Small Shops campaign last March. And one of the three or four most common recurring reasons given for closure is competition from new Tesco and Sainsbury's convenience stores. Bizarrely, today's report provide plenty of factual ammunition to suggest that all is not well in British food retailing. Then concludes exactly the opposite. It is like a well drilled football team creating an open goal opportunity for its centre forward, who then deliberately misses because he prefers the score as it is. In its 269 pages the report details how a nation of small shops has been supplanted by superstore Britain. In 1950 there were as many as 45,000 butchers and greengrocers. By 2000 there were just 10,000 - and presumably now a whole lot less. It is worse in some parts of London. In my neck of the woods, Hammersmith W6, there were around 30 local butchers in the early Seventies, virtually one for every block. Now there is just one - the admirable Stenton's. Tesco has had its eye on west London for many years. Historically this wealthy residential area has been Sainsbury's and Waitrose country with Tesco largely confined to its Brook Green and Warwick Road redoubts. But that has changed in the past five years with clusters of Express and Metro stores springing up throughout the area . A largish new Tesco is set to open near the Standard's offices on Kensington High Street any day now and the company is very keen to develop a superstore in Hammersmith. You cannot help admiring Tesco. They just keep coming. Like Rasputin, they are virtually impossible to kill off - even when councils turn down their applications. Maybe Sir Terry is right. Perhaps it is just the 5 per cent of the chattering classes who raise their noses in their air and the other 95 per cent really do love them. But that is not what our readers are saying. The Competition Commission today effectively gave a green light to supermarket growth. Indeed in some ways it said there should be far more. For those who value London's threatened retail biodiversity, these are worrying times.




